Comment Moderation – What’s your plan?

 Moderation?Kurt Greenbaum at Virtual St. Louis has posted a thought piece on comment moderation. His take on that can be summed up by this quote.

I’ve always considered that a small price to pay for the instant gratification a reader can get by seeing a comment immediately.”

That’s a bold choice in these days where spam bots can quickly overrun a blog.  However, modern blogging software and hosting systems have become much better at sorting out spam comments.

The WordPress hosting service has captured hundreds of spam comments for my blogs. There have only been a handful of false positives where a true comment went to spam.

A bigger concern isn’t spam, but hateful or malicious comments.  In the case of Virtual St. Louis, a blog focused on a very opinionated community, it’s likely that the comments will get heated at times.  The question then becomes should the occasional over the top comment be allowed in order to reward the majority of commenters with seeing theirs right away.

Blogging tools offer various ways to moderate comments.  In the tools, the blogger can require all comments to be moderated, only first time commenters to be moderated, or no moderation to take place.  Also, the number of links in a comment can be set to trigger its moderation.

So far those options have worked well here at The Broad Brush, and apparently well enough at Virtual St. Louis.  As spammers get more sophisticated and our tolerances change, will these tools be enough?  Will blogs like Virtual St. Louis be able to keep their open comment policy?

What measures have you taken towards spam prevention and comment moderation at your blog? Are they working? Will they stand the test of time?

3 Responses to “Comment Moderation – What’s your plan?”

  1. 1 Kurt March 26, 2008 at 3:24 pm

    Good post. It’s something we wrestle with all the time here at the Post. That’s why I posted the item on my blog…because I was interested in points of view like this.

    Lots of papers are also inviting readers’ comments on stories — some of the largest include USAToday and the Washington Post. Neither of them has the resources to review ALL the story comments pre-publication, as far as I know. Some stories have hundreds of comments on them.

    So, it becomes important for sites like that to give the community tools to help self-police.

    In my shop, we also try to take special care with blog items that clearly have the potential to spin into malice and hateful comment (the Kirkwood shooting story comes to mind).

  2. 2 tojosan March 26, 2008 at 7:15 pm


    Thanks for dropping by. I see this posted with no moderation. 🙂

    I’ve commented on various sites such as the ones you mentioned and most allow direct commenting. I’d be willing to be there are some spam filters in place and some of those are likely key word driven.

    Being aware of potentially touchy subjects is half the battle.

  3. 3 Steven June 17, 2008 at 2:40 am

    I simply want to say that you wrote very interesting article.
    Hi, my name is Steven, and My site is steven

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: