Facebook, You’re Banished

Aaron Brazell aka Technosailor has dropped Facebook. You can read about it here, Facebook, You’re Banished.

For instance, earlier today I went in and declined 17 application requests and ignored 32 “Which Bible Character are you?” kinds of questions. It’s pointless noise that is distracting.

Aaron made not just a blanket statement about it, but provides a short video as well.  His comment above summarizes the main frustration well.  It’s all about usefulness.

Facebook applications are significantly more focused on games, quizzes and other time wasters than productivity oriented.  Chris Brogan shared only a handful when asked.  I find only a few add real value to my life and my objectives.

Facebook CartoonFacebook may soon be in a battle to keep it’s high end users, like Aaron, Scoble, and Brogan.  Those users don’t just desire sites to provide productivity enhancing environments, but require it.  Even sites such as LinkedIn and Dopplr might be in trouble if the time spent there isn’t directly resulting in new knowledge, bringing in business, or otherwise making lives easier.

OpenSocial claims to be a boon to social networking sites. Ultimately though, if the quality and usefulness of the applications doesn’t increase, then OpenSocial may only bring a geometric growth of the noise over value.  Are we doomed have all social networking sites become useless?

The question is really not will there be more game and quiz applications, that’s a given. The real question is will sites find more real tool applications to use.  Behind that even, what might drive their development.

The big problem is that application developers are driven mostly be ad revenue right now. This is even true of sites such as LinkedIn, which I use.  Sadly, game players are apparently into clicking on ads.

My suggestion is to create services where the value is high enough that even everyday folks like me will join up as a paying member.  Those sites then need to make their objects available to me where I want and need them, not just on their website. If I want a Dopplr widget on my browser, that’s common enough it should already be there.  Or how about Widgets on my desktop? Where’s my Grand Central notifier?  The concept of sites that users must visit might be fine for folks that have lots of time to spare visiting them, but busy people needs apps that will come to them. Mobile application versions is just one aspect. They need not to forget desktop and laptop users like me, that don’t want to open 10 tabs to see all my stuff.

Yes, I’ve ranted off course a bit, but it comes down to usefulness versus noise.  The noise isn’t just a steady trickle on Facebook, it’s a flood.  The pace is just picking up.  Aaron isn’t the first to weigh anchor and move on but he’s a strong sign of the movement away from such sites.

What’s your line? 10 invites? 100? 1000? What’s your camel back breaking app you’ll freak out over and drop Facebook for?

Advertisements

5 Responses to “Facebook, You’re Banished”


  1. 1 mousewords April 12, 2008 at 1:39 pm

    So very true. Not that the FaceBook apps aren’t enjoyable; but I always felt like the clamor of virtual gardens and pets and snowpeople resembled games of solitaire–yes, they’re fun, and I like to play them, but only when I have extra time on my hands. (Haha.)

    FaceBook has been a good way for me to keep connected to friends through games, but I find myself neglecting both games AND friends because I’m simply short on time to play.

    I value sites that can offer useful tools and efficiency along with the social aspect.

    If my virtual puppies wouldn’t starve to death on FaceBook, and my profile could include a task scheduler or something of the like…I’d be there a whole lot more often. (And play a round of Scrabulous & draw some graffiti while I’m at it. 😉 )

  2. 2 Todd Jordan April 12, 2008 at 3:19 pm

    Thanks for the excellent and extensive input on this topic. I find myself focusing on just those games that take little bits of time and low maintenance. I’ve had gardens, flowers, pets, and even been on the wagon trail again. 🙂

    Few of these hold much satisfaction though. For more productivity, it’s best to stick to Backpack and similar sites. It’d be great though if Facebook had some apps like that though, or plug in apps from Zoho or something. Less sites to visit is always better for me.

    Thanks again.

  3. 3 Cynthia Armistead April 13, 2008 at 1:36 pm

    I love the comic! May I repost it with a link to this post?

    I’d be much happier if Facebook had a blanket “opt out of all application invites/messages” somewhere. Having it block every single application as you receive nonsense from it is ridiculous. If I say I don’t want any Vampire silliness, it stands to reason that I’m also disinterested in Zombies, Werewolves, Pirates, Slayers, and whatever other derivatives come up.

    I did turn off the email notifications, but that means that I also don’t get friend requests, or notifications of messages from real people. I can’t imagine why people won’t just send me an actual email, though, or leave a comment on my blog. There’s no convenient way to ask people to do that in my profile that I can see, either.

  4. 4 Todd Jordan April 13, 2008 at 3:06 pm

    Cynthia,

    Thanks for dropping by and giving some feedback on this. Yes, more options for control of messaging should exist. Facebook should enforce design requirements to be part of a universal message opt out for each application. One that perhaps works off of one profile flag for all of them.

    I’ve started blocking apps as I receive invites. You know you can now block app invites from a particular user as well.

    Thanks again.

  5. 5 Heartburn Home Remedy April 15, 2009 at 7:54 am

    Hey, nice tips. Perhaps I’ll buy a glass of beer to that man from that chat who told me to go to your blog 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s





%d bloggers like this: